Debunking 8 Common Myths About Adopting Shelter Pets (2024)

Thousands of families across the United States experience the joy and companionship that pets bring into their lives. This number continues to grow each year as more and more Americans open their hearts and homes to new pets.

If you're among those looking to add a new four-legged friend to your family, adopting a dog or cat from a shelter is a great option to not only find the pet of your dreams but also save lives and help alleviate the overpopulation crisis plaguing so many shelters and rescue organizations.

Support for animal shelters and helping displaced animals find a forever home has grown increasingly over the years. In fact, Americans celebrate National Adopt A Shelter Pet Day to raise awareness about the millions of companion animals living in shelters while awaiting their forever homes. Above and beyond this holiday, we all know that any day is a great day to bring about awareness about the option to add a new pet to your family or spend some time volunteering at a local animal shelter, too. Over the years, you've probably heard a lot of myths about shelter pets. As veterinarians, we're here to separate fact from fiction. In this blog post, we'll debunk a few of the most common myths about shelter pets. We've seen countless success stories of shelter pets finding loving homes and thriving, and we hope to encourage you to consider adopting when you are ready to become a pet owner or bring home an additional four-legged family member.

Debunking 8 Common Myths About Adopting Shelter Pets (1)

Myth #1: Shelter Pets Are Damaged Goods

Many folks assume that animals who end up in shelters must have some sort of damage. After all, why would anyone surrender a perfectly good pet to a shelter? In reality, people give up animals for many reasons. Sometimes, they have allergies or personal issues. They might be going through a divorce or moving somewhere that doesn't allow pets. Not having the money to afford a pet's care is, unfortunately, another common reason for pet parents to surrender perfectly healthy and happy pets.

In many situations, dogs, cats, and other pets end up in shelters at no fault of their own. Most are perfectly adoptable and far from "damaged." They may need some extra training, but with love and patience, most of the animals in shelters are worthy pets.

Myth #2: Shelter Animals Are Often Sick

While it's true that shelters take in pets with health issues, they address those problems before putting an animal up for adoption. Shelters go to great lengths to care for pets and provide appropriate treatment for illnesses, ensuring that the pets are in good health before adoption.

Depending on the shelter, pets often get the following done during their time there (if needed):

If an animal has a chronic disease, like diabetes, the shelter will make sure they are stable and provide information about their health before adoption. No shelter knowingly adopts out sick animals — especially without notifying potential adopters.

Myth #3: Shelter Dogs Are Aggressive

It's a common misconception that most dogs end up in shelters for displaying aggressive behavior. Sure, there are some aggressive dogs in shelters. But they certainly do not make up the majority of a shelter's population. Most shelters will do a behavioral assessment for every dog that’s admitted. Dogs are typically tested for food and leash aggression, handling habits (touching ears, feet, muzzles, etc), and territorial/ other pet aggression. If a dog does have any behavioral problems, shelter employees will make potential adopters aware of such issues before adoption.

Myth #4: You Can't Find Purebred Animals in Shelters

Surprisingly, this is entirely untrue. According to numerous studies, around 25% of the dogs and cats in shelters are purebreds. There are countless breed-specific rescue groups and shelters spread throughout the nation. Finding a specific breed to adopt might take more time than buying a pet from a breeder, but it's well worth the effort when you get the breed you want and get to make a difference in an animal's life.

Myth #5: Shelters Only Have Dogs and Cats

It's true that some shelters only have dogs and cats. However, there are many others where you can adopt just about any type of pet imaginable, including birds, rabbits, guinea pigs, and more. There are even large animal and livestock rescues with pigs, goats, horses, and more if you're looking to add this type of animal to your family.

Myth #6: Buying From a Breeder Is Safer Because of Bloodlines

People often go to breeders to get purebred animals and avoid getting a pet with aggression issues. While bloodlines and medical histories are useful tools for evaluating pets, they have very little value in predicting behavior or potential health problems. According to the ASPCA, purebred animals are often predisposed to certain medical issues. Genetic disorders are also common among purebreds.

Myth #7: If You Adopt an Older Pet, They Won't Bond

There is no correlation between an animal's age and their ability to bond with their owners and other household pets. Adopting a senior pet offers numerous benefits, and there's no need to worry about their ability to bond. Senior cats and dogs show just as much love and affection as their younger counterparts. In this case, age is just a number.

Myth #8: Shelter Pets Are Dirty

It's common for pets entering shelters to look a bit dirty or scraggly. After a bath, haircut (if needed), medication, and vaccinations, though, they look and feel much better. All shelters check pets for external parasites and provide flea treatments as needed. Most shelters offer at least basic grooming services regularly to maintain pets' coats, nails, etc. Sometimes, professional groomers even donate their services to help pets look their best so they're more likely to find forever homes.

Additionally, shelter cats aren't any more likely to be "dirty" in terms of not using a litter box than a cat you buy from a breeder. An underlying health or behavioral problem usually causes litter box avoidance.

Debunking 8 Common Myths About Adopting Shelter Pets (2)

Consider Adding a Shelter Pet to Your Family

No matter what time of year, think about the message of Adopt A Shelter Pet Day, and consider adding a new furry friend to your family. Shelter pets have a lot of love to offer, and you’ll feel great knowing that you helped an animal in need. If you decide to open up your heart and home to a shelter pet, we are here for you with all of the knowledge and resources you may need to pick the right pet for your family and ensure they have a long and happy life.

Finding a reputable shelter or rescue organization to adopt your new furry friend is easier than you might think! Start by checking out local shelters online, where you can read reviews and see how other pet lovers rate them. For a more personal touch, visit the shelters in person to get a feel for the place, chat with staff about what animals are available, and learn about their adoption process. Make sure they provide top-notch medical care and behavioral assessments to ensure you're bringing home a happy, healthy pet.

If you have questions and you'd like to reach out to us, you can call us directly at (201) 350-1802, or you can email us at [emailprotected]. Don't forget to follow us on social media Facebook, Instagram.

Debunking 8 Common Myths About Adopting Shelter Pets (2024)

FAQs

Debunking 8 Common Myths About Adopting Shelter Pets? ›

Disadvantages of adopting from a shelter

The history of aggressive behavior may be unknown. Shelter dogs can have some training issues because they often come with different life experiences. They require patience and time to adapt.

What are the cons of adopting a pet from a shelter? ›

Disadvantages of adopting from a shelter

The history of aggressive behavior may be unknown. Shelter dogs can have some training issues because they often come with different life experiences. They require patience and time to adapt.

What happens to dogs that don t get adopted from the shelter? ›

Adoptable animals are generally held and placed with a new family; animals that are too sick, old, or unsociable to be adopted are euthanized. Once a shelter gains title to the animal, it can do with the animal as it sees fit, and its decision will be upheld by courts as long as the shelter complied with state law.

Why is it better to adopt a pet from a shelter than buy? ›

Because adoption helps more than just one animal. Overburdened shelters take in millions of stray, abused and lost animals every year, and by adopting an animal, you're making room for others.

Is it wrong to give an animal back to the shelter? ›

In most instances no, it's not. Unless you're returning the pet for unprovoked aggression or an untreatable illness, they are probably going to find a new home where they fit right in. Even knowing that they'll be adopted again, you're still going to feel crummy. That's normal.

Why do people not adopt shelter dogs? ›

The stigma behind the shelter pets

Although many animal lovers see adopting a dog, cat, or other pets as a badge of honor, many others perceive rescue animals as needy, less healthy, and difficult to train. Therefore, most people don't prefer adopting pets from rescue or shelter homes; instead, they contact a breeder.

Is it bad to get a dog from a shelter? ›

Some Rescue Animals Have Special Needs

Sometimes, animals were surrendered for a reason or had previous owners who didn't treat them well. Some rescue animals therefore may have behavioral problems that some new pet owners may not be prepared to handle.

How many animals are euthanized in shelters each year? ›

About 7.6 million unwanted pets enter U.S. animal shelters every year, and about 2.7 million of them are euthanized—roughly 31 percent of dogs and 41 percent of cats, according to the American Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (www.aspca.org).

What do breeders do with unsold puppies? ›

In some cases, puppy mills may surrender their unsold puppies to shelters or rescues for rehabilitation. However, many shelters and rescues are overpopulated with dogs in need of a home, and puppy mills are a main contributor to this problem.

Why should puppy mills be banned? ›

Puppy mill operators maximize their profits by producing large numbers of puppies as quickly as possible. As a result, unsanitary conditions, disease, and neglect are rampant. Sign our pledge to boycott puppy mills.

Why is adopting a pet so expensive? ›

Adoption fees help cover the medical care of the animal while he or she waits for a new home, as well as food and transportation costs. These fees help to provide care for the other animals in the shelter or rescue group who may have medical bills that are much higher than any possible adoption fee.

Why do people say adopt don't shop? ›

The term “Adopt, don't shop” was coined as a part of an awareness campaign by Los Angeles-based Last Chance for Animals (LCA), an international, non-profit animal advocacy organization. It was to educate people about the benefits of adopting a pet from a shelter instead of buying from stores and puppy mills.

What is the 3 3 3 rule for dogs? ›

The 3-3-3 rule is a guideline for transitioning a rescue dog into its new home and helping it to settle in. It suggests that the first three days should be used for adjusting to its new surroundings, the next three weeks for training and bonding, and the first three months for continued socialization and training.

Why animal shelters should not euthanize? ›

Imagine a working environment in which 50% of those around you die every day. In wartime, that may be inevitable. But an animal shelter isn't a war zone and animals aren't dying for a noble or just cause. Killing healthy and treatable animals is debilitating and demoralizing for the people who have to do it.

Do rescue dogs know they are rescued? ›

The bottom line is, while dogs may not understand the concept of rescue, they definitely have the ability to recognize their owners through their senses and emotional connection.

How does living in a shelter affect dogs? ›

Being at the shelter means that at least the dog isn't loose or living in an unfit environment. That said, for many pups, a shelter can be a stressful environment that could cause their behaviors to change. For instance, kennel reactivity in shelter dogs is not uncommon.

What are the risks of adopting a dog? ›

Puppies can also suffer from fear, anxiety and other lasting behavioral problems. Sometimes these issues don't show up until people bring the puppy home, only to be confronted with unpredictable, expensive and oftentimes chronic medical issues.

What are the disadvantages of pet care? ›

Con: ownerships costs

The cost of pet ownership can be significant, including food, grooming, veterinary care, vaccinations and emergency medical expenses. Some breeds of dogs also have specific health issues, which lead to even higher healthcare costs. All this really adds up.

Is it normal to regret adopting a pet? ›

If so, know you are not alone. This phenomenon is very common and even has a name: Adopter's Remorse. It's a feeling of sudden panic, guilt, or regret one experiences after adopting a pet.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Terence Hammes MD

Last Updated:

Views: 6356

Rating: 4.9 / 5 (69 voted)

Reviews: 92% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Terence Hammes MD

Birthday: 1992-04-11

Address: Suite 408 9446 Mercy Mews, West Roxie, CT 04904

Phone: +50312511349175

Job: Product Consulting Liaison

Hobby: Jogging, Motor sports, Nordic skating, Jigsaw puzzles, Bird watching, Nordic skating, Sculpting

Introduction: My name is Terence Hammes MD, I am a inexpensive, energetic, jolly, faithful, cheerful, proud, rich person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.