Impossible Lemon Pie Recipe - Southern Plate (2024)

Pie

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

With a sweet, custard-like, and zesty lemon filling, this Impossible Lemon Pie recipe is quick and easy to make using a Bisquick mix.

Jump to Recipe

Every lemon pie I’ve ever tried has been immediately declared my favorite. So today I’m sharing my favorite for this moment in my life: Impossible Lemon Pie. You will be blown away at how little time it takes to make this pie. Seriously, don’t blink or you’ll miss it!

In addition to using ingredients you probably already have on hand (like butter, milk, sugar, eggs, vanilla extract, and lemon juice), this pie also makes its own crust. It was a part of the “Bisquick Impossible Pie” craze of the 70s. Back when the latest technology was a walkman cassette player and everyone who owned a cassette became a master surgeon at getting the “guts” back in with a pencil when it got hung up.

Cassettes may be out but this lemon pie recipe is one that has stood the test of time. It’s just sweet enough with a nice eggy texture to it that’s somewhat reminiscent of a chess pie (I’ll put links to my chess pie recipes at the bottom of this post). I just know you’ll want to pop this recipe in your files.

Now we need some pie, Impossible Lemon Pie to be exact. Because I am always ready to testify that lemon desserts are like eating sunshine and I don’t know a single person, especially in 2018, who couldn’t use a little extra boost of sunshine in their lives. Speaking of, here are more lovely lemon desserts: easy lemon bar recipe (with video tutorial),lemon angel food cake roll,lemon icebox cake, andlemon blossom cookies.

Recipe Ingredients

Milk
Sugar
Bisquick baking mix
Eggs
Butter
Vanilla extract
Lemon juice

Helpful Kitchen Tools

9-inch Pie Pan
Blender (Splurge)
Blender (Budget Friendly)

How to Make Impossible Lemon Pie

Spray a 9-inch pie plate generously with cooking spray.

Then place all ingredients in a blender.

Storage

Refrigerate leftovers for up to 1 week. You can serve this Impossible Lemon Pie straight from the fridge if you prefer, or zap it quickly in the microwave.
You can also freeze leftovers for up to 3 months.

Recipe Notes

If you have a craving for a Coconut Lemon Impossible Pie, you can add1 cup of unsweetened coconut flakes.
You can use either bottled or fresh lemon juice. If using fresh, you can also add 1/2 a lemon zest.
Serve your lemon pie with whipped cream, a dusting of lemon zest, or a dusting of powdered sugar.
If you like, add 1/8 teaspoon of nutmeg for a little hint of spice.

Recipe FAQs

Why is it called an Impossible Pie?

Originating in the 70s, it’s suggested they’re called Impossible Pies because they’re impossible to mess up. The impossibly easy recipe was first printed on the back of Bisquick boxes. I mean, seeing as you just add all of your ingredients to a blender to create a blender pie, they might be onto something. And hey, it doesn’t hurt that they’re also impossibly delicious!