Lemon Blueberry Cheesecake Cups Recipe | We are not Martha (2024)

These Lemon Blueberry Cheesecake Cups practically scream spring with their vibrant colors and bright flavors. They can be assembled and baked quickly and topped with whipped cream, blueberry sauce, and lemon zest for an extra touch.

Spring is in the air!! Kinda, sorta, maybe. OK, so it's currently like 40 degrees and raining out and there's a little snowflake emoji showing on my weather app for tomorrow (what the heck!), but I'm still fully in the spring spirit and you can't stop me. Not that you were planning to. I think pretty much everyone is just as ready for spring as I am. My poor dog is especially ready as all she wants to do is go on long walks and play outside. Little does she know I'm putting her in my own personal doggy bootcamp this spring to whip her into full emotional shape. She's almost three now and still has major anxiety issues and while she loves walks, she tends to panic around other people and dogs (and yes, sometimes mailboxes and basketball hoops). Like, I'm that girl who's all "no, you can't come pet my dog" and who will literally turn and go in another direction if I see a person or dog coming our way. So, once the weather is warm, it's go-time.

Until then, I'll sit shivering in my house waiting for the sun to come out and shoving cheesecake cups into my mouth. Don't judge me. It's been a long winter. My grocery store has been fully stocked with blueberries for a few weeks now and every single time I've bought them, I've been disappointed. They're just not there yet. But blueberries really give me that full spring feeling and I want to be enjoying them so badly right now. So, I bought a big bag of Wyman's frozen wild blueberries last week. Did you know that wild blueberries are actually the healthiest blueberries? I've basically just been eating them right out of the bag. Before the bag was completely gone, I decided I needed to do some springtime baking, so I made these Lemon Blueberry Cheesecake Cups. They're adorable and bite-sized and topped with whipped cream and a little extra blueberry sauce.

Which you can also eat right out of the jar with a spoon, if you're so inclined.

LEMON BLUEBERRY CHEESECAKE CUPS RECIPE

These cheesecake cups are also incredibly easy to make. I feel like there's a misconception that cheesecake is really difficult and time-consuming and maybe that's true if you're dealing with a big cheesecake that requires a water bath and cracking the oven open at the exact perfect time. But cheesecake cups? They're easy. And they bake quickly. And if there's a little crack on the surface here and there, no big deal because whipped cream covers any and all cosmetic damage.

Instead of making a crumb crust for the cheesecake cups, I went with a super simple Oreo cookie bottom instead. You literally just place an Oreo on the bottom of your cupcake paper. I used Golden Oreo cookies here, but you can definitely use lemon if you want additional lemon flavor. I accidentally bought double-stuffed cookies (I had no idea Golden even came double stuffed. Mind blown!), but think the regular kind is better here. The cheesecake gives you more than enough creaminess.

I love the little swirl action we've got going on and the bright vibrant blueberries in every cup.

These cheesecake cups are also great for portion control! Being around a whole cheesecake can be dangerous. Heck, being around a slice of cheesecake can be dangerous. But a cheesecake cup? Nice and dainty and perfect for a little sweet treat. OK, so you might be in trouble given that this recipe makes 12 of them... But surely you have some friends and neighbors you can share with?

And now I'm fully obsessed with the idea that lemonade season is coming (have you seen my lavender lemonade mojito recipe??) and soon I will be sitting on my deck with a cold lemonade (ahem, lemonade co*cktail) and a big bowl of fresh blueberries. Though my frozen wild blueberries will also make a fabulous summer snack. And cheesecake. There's really no bad time of the year for cheesecake. And I have a lot of missed time to make up for considering I went years and years thinking I was a cheesecake hater. These lemon blueberry cheesecake cups are the most perfect spring and summer dessert, but with frozen blueberries, I might be making these in the dead of winter when I need a little extra positivity boost.

The rain is seriously coming down now and I'm considering turning on my gas fireplace to warm up (in April. Wah). Or maybe I'll just head to the fridge, grab another lemon blueberry cheesecake bite, close my eyes, and pretend the sun is shining and the spring vibes are flowing.

Why are you excited for spring to come?

If you love these Lemon Blueberry Cheesecake Cups, check out my Strawberry Shortcake Cheesecake Bars and my Cinnamon Bun Oreo Cheesecake Bars. I also love these Turtle Cheesecake Bars from Midwest Foodies!

📖 Recipe

More Dessert Recipes